Subject: Fw: multi-year PBL Social Welfare ex-post evaluation
From: Tamar Avalishvili <[email-masked]>
To: "[email-masked]" <[email-masked]>
Cc: Ioseb Skhirtladze <[email-masked]>, natia mshvidobadze <[email-masked]>, Salome Chakvetadze <[email-masked]>, Naiko Sadunishvili <[email-masked]>, Ketevan Goginashvili <[email-masked]>, Tamar Barkalaia <[email-masked]>
Date: Thu, 09 Jul 2020 09:38:20 +0000

Dear Valentina,

Could you please contact directly the colleagues from MOLSA on the ex-post evaluation process of Social Welfare PBL. I have put them in cc.

Kind Regards,

Tamar

De : SPINA Valentina

Envoyé : mercredi 24 juin 2020 13:06

À : 'Salome Chakvetadze'

Cc : ASSAYAG Gaelle; 'Naiko Sadunishvili'

Objet : RE: multi-year PBL Social Welfare ex-post evaluation

Dear Salome ,

I hope this email finds you well.

Do you have any news concerning the document to be reviewed and the information about the project evaluation process ?

Thank you very much in advance.

Best regards,

Valentina

Valentina SPINA

Chargée de mission stratégie et opérations pour le Sud Caucase

Strategy and operations officer for the South Caucasus

+995 32 2 500 277 ext.104 |+995 595 975 523

@AFD_France |AGENCE FRANÇAISE DE DÉVELOPPEMENT

34 av. Chavchavadze - BC Pixel 8th Floor - 0179 Tbilisi| GEORGIA

#MondeEnCommun | www.afd.fr

De : SPINA Valentina

Envoyé : jeudi 11 juin 2020 17:36

À : 'Salome Chakvetadze'

Cc : ASSAYAG Gaelle; Naiko Sadunishvili

Objet : RE: multi-year PBL Social Welfare ex-post evaluation

Dear Salome,

Thank you very much, we keep in touch and do not hesitate to contact me should you have any question.

Best regards,

Valentina

Valentina SPINA

Chargée de mission stratégie et opérations pour le Sud Caucase

Strategy and operations officer for the South Caucasus

+995 32 2 500 277 ext.104 |+995 595 975 523

@AFD_France |AGENCE FRANÇAISE DE DÉVELOPPEMENT

34 av. Chavchavadze - BC Pixel 8th Floor - 0179 Tbilisi| GEORGIA

#MondeEnCommun | www.afd.fr

De : Salome Chakvetadze [mailto:[email-masked]]

Envoyé : jeudi 11 juin 2020 15:20

À : SPINA Valentina

Cc : ASSAYAG Gaelle; Naiko Sadunishvili

Objet : RE: multi-year PBL Social Welfare ex-post evaluation

Dear Valentina,

My apologies for late response. We will check details with MOILHSA and will give you the final answer.

As for the attached document, we will review it.

Thank you.

Kind regards,

Salome

From: SPINA Valentina

Sent: Thursday, June 11, 2020 3:03 PM

To: Salome Chakvetadze

Cc: ASSAYAG Gaelle

Subject: RE: multi-year PBL Social Welfare ex-post evaluation

Dear Salome,

I hope this email finds you well.

I am coming back to you on two topics. The first is about our request of information that you can find below in my previous email – would you, by any chance, have any answer on that? Thank you in advance.

My second question concerns our PBL on pensions ( CGE1008). When the convention was signed in 2017, the NCO public brief was not included in it so we would need to have your approval of such document (which is attached
and which contains all the information that ca be published in the public database).

Thank you very much and please let me know in case you have any question.

Best regards,

Valentina

Valentina SPINA

Chargée de mission stratégie et opérations pour le Sud Caucase

Strategy and operations officer for the South Caucasus

+995 32 2 500 277 ext.104 |+995 595 975 523

@AFD_France |AGENCE FRANÇAISE DE DÉVELOPPEMENT

34 av. Chavchavadze - BC Pixel 8th Floor - 0179 Tbilisi| GEORGIA

#MondeEnCommun | www.afd.fr

De : SPINA Valentina

Envoyé : lundi 25 mai 2020 10:30

À : 'Salome Chakvetadze'

Cc : ASSAYAG Gaelle

Objet : RE: multi-year PBL Social Welfare ex-post evaluation

Dear Salome,

Once again congratulations on the signature ! We are glad everything went well.

I am writing to know if you had time to have a look at my previous email concerning the ex-post evaluation of our PBL on social welfare.

Would you have any answer to my questions below and in case you don’t, who should I contact to have more information ?

Thank you very much in advance,

Best regards,

Valentina

Valentina SPINA

Chargée de mission stratégie et opérations pour le Sud Caucase

Strategy and operations officer for the South Caucasus

+995 32 2 500 277 ext.104 |+995 595 975 523

@AFD_France |AGENCE FRANÇAISE DE DÉVELOPPEMENT

34 av. Chavchavadze - BC Pixel 8th Floor - 0179 Tbilisi| GEORGIA

#MondeEnCommun | www.afd.fr

De : SPINA Valentina

Envoyé : jeudi 7 mai 2020 11:13

À : 'Salome Chakvetadze'

Cc : ASSAYAG Gaelle

Objet : multi-year PBL Social Welfare ex-post evaluation

Dear Salome ,

I hope this email finds you well despite the current situation.

I am writing because AFD is planning to do an ex-post evaluation of the multi-year PBL on Social Welfare.

The main goal of the evaluation is to analyze the impacts of the reforms supported by the PBL and to capitalize on good practices and lessons learnt within the framework of this project to improve our further PBL operations
in this specific sector but also beyond it. Depending on the evaluation, we could also consider providing a specific support to the entities in charge of public policy assessment within the framework of a future PBL.

The first step  would be to understand how the impact and efficiency of public policies are assessed in Georgia. To do so, we propose to organize a preliminary call with all the entities responsible for such activities
to (i) get a better understanding of public policy evaluation process and (ii) present AFD’s approach and methodology for ex-post evaluation. Based on this exchange, we could then develop ToRs for conducting the evaluation of the Social Welfare PBL.

If we are not mistaken , the State Audit Office of Georgia should be involved in the process, and probably as well the MOF and the MOHLSA. Who are the other entities that should be involved in the evaluation process
?

Thank you very much for your time and please let us know should you have any question.

Best regards,

Valentina

Valentina SPINA

Chargée de mission stratégie et opérations pour le Sud Caucase

Strategy and operations officer for the South Caucasus

+995 32 2 500 277 ext.104 |+995 595 975 523

@AFD_France |AGENCE FRANÇAISE DE DÉVELOPPEMENT

34 av. Chavchavadze - BC Pixel 8th Floor - 0179 Tbilisi| GEORGIA

#MondeEnCommun | www.afd.fr